The acquisition of Deshaun Watson by the Cleveland Browns in March 2022 sent shockwaves throughout the NFL. Not only did the Browns trade a significant package of draft picks to the Houston Texans, but they also handed Watson a contract that redefined the quarterback market. This article delves into the intricacies of Deshaun Watson’s contract, exploring its unprecedented fully guaranteed nature, its financial implications for the Browns, and the questions that have lingered in the minds of fans and analysts alike.
The Groundbreaking Terms: Five Years, $230 Million Fully Guaranteed
On March 18, 2022, Deshaun Watson inked a five-year, $230 million contract with the Cleveland Browns. What made this deal truly unique was the inclusion of $230 million in fully guaranteed money – a first of its kind for a contract of this magnitude in NFL history. This meant that regardless of performance, injury, or off-field issues (to a certain extent), Watson was entitled to the entire sum.
The contract structure included a $44.965 million signing bonus and an average annual value of $46 million. The yearly breakdown of the contract has been subject to restructurings to manage the Browns’ salary cap, but the fundamental guarantee remains.
Key Contract Details:
Duration: 5 years (2022-2026)
Total Value: $230 million
Guaranteed Money: $230 million (fully guaranteed at signing)
Signing Bonus: $44.965 million
Average Annual Value: $46 million
No-Trade Clause: Included throughout the entire contract, giving Watson significant control over his future.
Why the Unprecedented Guarantee?
The Browns’ decision to offer a fully guaranteed contract to Watson was highly debated, especially considering the off-field allegations he was facing at the time of the trade. Several factors likely contributed to this unprecedented move:
Acquiring a Franchise Quarterback: The Browns had been searching for a long-term, elite quarterback for decades. Watson, despite the controversy, was viewed as a player with top-tier potential capable of elevating the franchise.
Competition in the Trade Market: Multiple teams were reportedly interested in acquiring Watson. The fully guaranteed contract likely served as a significant incentive to secure his commitment to Cleveland.
Setting a New Market: The Browns might have felt the need to push the boundaries of quarterback contracts to land a player of Watson’s perceived caliber.
Financial Implications and Salary Cap Management
A contract of this size, especially with the full guarantee, has significant implications for the Cleveland Browns’ salary cap. The cap hit for Watson is spread out over the life of the contract, but the guaranteed nature means the team has limited flexibility if they were to move on from him.
To manage the cap effectively, the Browns have restructured Watson’s contract multiple times. These restructurings typically involve converting a portion of his base salary into a signing bonus, which is then prorated over the remaining years of the contract (and sometimes void years added for further flexibility). While this creates immediate cap relief, it pushes larger cap hits into future years and increases the dead cap if the player is released or traded.
Deshaun Watson’s Salary Cap Hits (as of May 2025):
2022: $9.395 million
2023: $19.057 million
2024: $27.942 million
2025 (Projected): Approximately $72.73 million
2026 (Projected): Approximately $81.68 million
The significant jump in cap hits for 2025 and 2026 is a consequence of previous restructurings. The Browns will likely need to continue managing his contract to maintain salary cap flexibility for the rest of the roster.
Performance and Return on Investment
The on-field performance of Deshaun Watson since arriving in Cleveland has been a major point of discussion. Due to an 11-game suspension in 2022 and season-ending injuries in both 2023 and 2024 (shoulder and Achilles), Watson has played in a limited number of games for the Browns. His performance in those games has been inconsistent, and he has yet to replicate the Pro Bowl-caliber play he displayed in Houston.
This has led to significant scrutiny of the contract and the trade, with many analysts and fans questioning the return on investment for the Browns. The team invested heavily in Watson, both in terms of draft capital and salary, and his limited availability and fluctuating performance have hindered their progress.
Injury Concerns and Contract Protection
Adding to the complexity of Watson’s contract are the recent injury setbacks. His season-ending Achilles injury in October 2024, followed by a re-rupture in January 2025, has raised concerns about his long-term availability and performance.
Interestingly, reports have emerged about an insurance addendum in Watson’s contract that could provide the Browns with some financial relief in case of injury preventing him from fulfilling his duties. This policy could potentially reimburse the Browns a significant portion of the money paid while he was injured and his 2025 compensation, potentially providing salary cap credit in the future. However, the actual payout from the insurance company is not guaranteed and could be subject to legal interpretations of the policy.
Potential Future Scenarios and the “Dead Cap” Conundrum
The fully guaranteed nature of Watson’s contract makes any potential departure from the Browns financially challenging. If the Browns were to release or trade Watson, they would be saddled with a massive “dead cap” hit – the remaining guaranteed money that still counts against their salary cap.
Dead Cap Implications (as of May 2025):
Releasing or trading Watson before June 1, 2025, would result in a dead cap hit of over $167 million.
A post-June 1, 2025, release or trade would split the dead cap hit between 2025 and 2026, but it would still be a substantial amount (around $81 million in 2025 and $85 million in 2026).
These figures highlight the financial constraints the Browns face due to Watson’s contract, limiting their ability to make significant roster changes if they decide to move on from him.
Restructuring for Cap Relief: A Double-Edged Sword
The Browns have utilized contract restructurings to create immediate salary cap space. While this helps in the short term to build a competitive roster around Watson (when healthy), it has long-term consequences:
Increased Future Cap Hits: Restructuring pushes more significant cap charges into later years of the contract.
Higher Dead Cap: It increases the amount of dead money the team would incur if they were to release or trade the player in the future.
Limited Long-Term Flexibility: Continuously restructuring contracts can limit the team’s ability to maneuver financially in the long run.
The Browns’ repeated restructurings of Watson’s deal reflect their commitment to him in the short term while also highlighting the challenges of managing such a unique contract.
FAQs
What are the key details of Deshaun Watson’s contract with the Cleveland Browns?
Deshaun Watson signed a fully guaranteed five-year, $230 million contract with the Cleveland Browns in March 2022. This deal includes an average annual salary of $46 million and is notable for being the first fully guaranteed contract of its magnitude in NFL history. The contract spans from 2022 through 2026, with Watson set to become a free agent in 2027.
How has Watson’s contract impacted the Browns’ salary cap?
Watson’s contract has significantly influenced the Browns’ salary cap management. To alleviate cap pressures, the Browns have restructured his contract multiple times. In March 2025, they converted $44.745 million of his 2025 salary into a signing bonus, reducing his 2025 cap hit by approximately $35.8 million. However, this move increased his cap hits for 2026 and 2027 by $8.949 million each.
What are the financial implications if the Browns decide to release Watson?
Releasing Watson would have substantial financial repercussions due to the structure of his fully guaranteed contract. If the Browns were to cut him in 2025, they would incur a dead cap hit of $172.3 million, making such a move financially unfeasible. Even in 2026, the dead cap hit would be $135.4 million.
Has Watson’s contract been restructured more than once?
Yes, the Browns have restructured Watson’s contract multiple times to manage salary cap constraints. These restructures typically involve converting portions of his base salary into signing bonuses, which can be prorated over the remaining years of the contract, thereby reducing immediate cap hits but increasing future financial obligations.
What is the current status of Watson’s health and playing prospects?
Watson suffered a torn Achilles tendon in October 2024 and underwent surgery. He re-injured the same tendon in January 2025, requiring a second surgery. These injuries have cast doubt on his availability for the 2025 season, with some reports suggesting he may miss the entire year.
Are there any insurance provisions in Watson’s contract related to injuries?
Yes, Watson’s contract includes insurance clauses that could allow the Browns to recover a portion of his salary if he is unable to play due to injury. Specifically, they could potentially recoup up to $58.176 million, covering parts of his 2024 and 2025 compensation.
How does Watson’s contract compare to other NFL quarterback contracts?
Watson’s contract was groundbreaking at the time of signing due to its full guarantees. While other quarterbacks have since signed lucrative deals, the full guarantee aspect of Watson’s contract remains relatively unique and has influenced contract negotiations league-wide.
What are the long-term financial implications for the Browns due to Watson’s contract?
The restructures and guarantees in Watson’s contract have led to significant future cap hits. For instance, his cap hit for 2026 is projected to be $81.6 million. These figures will limit the Browns’ financial flexibility in upcoming seasons.
How has Watson performed since joining the Browns?
Since joining the Browns, Watson has played in 19 games over three seasons, with mixed performances. Injuries and off-field issues have limited his availability and effectiveness, contributing to the team’s struggles during his tenure.
What is the general perception of Watson’s contract within the NFL community?
Watson’s contract has been a subject of significant debate. Critics argue that the fully guaranteed nature of the deal, combined with his limited on-field contributions and off-field controversies, make it one of the most problematic contracts in NFL history.
To conclude
Deshaun Watson’s contract with the Cleveland Browns stands as one of the most scrutinized deals in NFL history. The fully guaranteed five-year, $230 million agreement was unprecedented at the time of signing and has since had profound implications for both the player and the franchise.
From a financial perspective, the contract has placed considerable strain on the Browns’ salary cap management. Multiple restructures have been necessary to maintain cap compliance, often pushing financial obligations into future years and limiting the team’s flexibility in roster building. The potential dead cap hits associated with releasing Watson are so substantial that the team is effectively committed to him for the duration of the contract.
On the field, Watson’s tenure with the Browns has been marred by injuries and inconsistent performance. His Achilles injuries have raised serious concerns about his future availability and effectiveness as a starting quarterback. Off the field, past allegations and suspensions have further complicated his standing within the organization and among fans.
The broader NFL community views Watson’s contract as a cautionary tale. While it set a new precedent for player guarantees, it also highlighted the risks teams assume when committing significant resources to a single player, especially one with potential off-field issues. The Browns’ experience underscores the importance of thorough due diligence and the potential long-term ramifications of contract structures.
As the Browns navigate the challenges posed by Watson’s contract, their decisions will likely influence future contract negotiations across the league. Teams may become more cautious in offering fully guaranteed deals, and players may need to balance the desire for guarantees with the understanding of the potential constraints such contracts can impose on team building.
In summary, Deshaun Watson’s contract has become a pivotal case study in NFL contract negotiations, salary cap management, and the complex interplay between player performance, financial commitments, and organizational strategy.
To read more , click here
